Dear Jen, I just found your blog while searching for Urban be redirected here Decay 24/7 reviews, and now you've inspired me to try L'Oreal HIP pencils. I love to save money on make-up.I'll definitely keep reading your blog, because you totally understand the woes of being monolid. This is the best eyeliner pencil for super oily lids (or very hot days). Since it was made for the waterline, so you know a little sweat and water won’t hurt it. It glides on like butter, but once it sets itstays.“I’ve got oily lids so most eyeliners smudge after just a few hours. This is the only one that lasted all day!” says one eyeliner review. Thanks for reviewing this! I saw this at Sephora and wondered why I needed a specific waterline pencil. I was tempted to buy it because I like Urban Decay, but $20 is kinda steep for a pencil that I may or may not need. I8217;ll be passing on this one.